• Daily Illinois
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Sitemap
  • Write For Us
Daily illinois - USA | News, Sports & Updates Web Magazine
  • Covid-19
  • News
    • All
    • Business
    • Education
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • World
    Why Opt for Online MBA Programs: Unveiling the Advantages Over Traditional In-Person Learning

    Why Opt for Online MBA Programs: Unveiling the Advantages Over Traditional In-Person Learning

    Mastering Snapchat for Business: A Comprehensive Guide

    Mastering Snapchat for Business: A Comprehensive Guide

    The Role of Ethical Leadership in Business Success

    The Role of Ethical Leadership in Business Success

    The Rise of Cobots: How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    Common Employee Challenges In 2023 & How To Manage Them

    Common Employee Challenges In 2023 & How To Manage Them

    Effective Stakeholder Management Strategies for Building Trust

    Stakeholder Management Strategy for Building Trust

    A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right Business Diploma Program for You

    A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right Business Diploma Program for You

    Ulysses S. Grant Quotes

    50+ Ulysses S. Grant Quotes: Inspirational Words from a Great Leader

    George Washington Quotes

    45+ George Washington Quotes about his Life, and Impact on American History

    The Benefits of Studying Electronics and Computer Engineering

    The Benefits of Studying Electronics and Computer Engineering

  • Science & Tech
    • All
    • Ai - Artificial Intelligence
    • Apps
    • Mobile
    5G Technology and IoT: A Revolutionary Partnership

    5G Technology and IoT: A Revolutionary Partnership

    Unlocking the Power of Symbols in Instagram Bio

    Unlocking the Power of Symbols in Instagram Bio

    Top 8 Best Music Download Apps for Android and iPhone in 2023

    Top 8 Best Music Download Apps for Android and iPhone in 2023

    The Rise of Cobots: How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    5G Technology: Positive Shift with Empowering Connectivity

    5G Technology: Positive Shift with Empowering Connectivity

    Reasons Collaborative Working as a Software Engineer is Important

    Reasons Collaborative Working as a Software Engineer is Important

    Effective Ways to Monetize Mobile App

    9 Effective Ways to Monetize Mobile App

    What is Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning

    What is Artificial Intelligence and Machine learning?

    The Top Python Development Skills for Developers in 2023

    The Top Python Development Skills for Developers in 2023?

    How to Delete a Friend on Snapchat

    How to Delete a Friend on Snapchat: A Step-by-Step Guide

  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    10 Must-Try Minecraft Seeds with Village for an Epic Adventure

    10 Must-Try Minecraft Seeds with Village for an Epic Adventure

    12 Best Anime Streaming Sites for Ultimate Otaku Experience

    12 Best Anime Streaming Sites for Ultimate Otaku Experience

    Free Streaming Sites Like 123movies

    Your Ultimate Guide to 12 Free Streaming Sites Like 123movies

    8 Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    8 Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    Exploring the Top 15 Games Like Minecraft

    Exploring the Top 15 Games Like Minecraft

    Choosing the Best Streaming Service: A Comprehensive Guide

    Choosing the Best Streaming Service: A Comprehensive Guide

    Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    6 Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    Best Apps for Android Music Downloads

    5 Best Apps for Android Music Downloads

    Make Clip on Twitch

    How to Make Clip on Twitch?

    The 12 Best Horror PC Games

    Best Horror PC Games: the scariest titles to play right now

    • F95zone
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
    Fostering Strong Sibling Bonds: A Guide to Lifelong Connections

    Fostering Strong Sibling Bonds: A Guide to Lifelong Connections

    Co-Parenting Tips: Putting Kids First After Divorce - A Complete Guide

    Co-Parenting Tips: Putting Kids First After Divorce – A Complete Guide

    The Art of Positive Discipline

    The Art of Positive Discipline: Effective Strategies for Parenting

    Ultimate Guide to Event Planning: From Concept to Execution

    Best Event Planning Guide From Concept to Execution

    Balance Nutrition Guide - Fuel Your Fitness Journey

    Balanced Nutrition Guide – Fuel Your Fitness Journey

    Gym Management Solutions: Streamlining Operations and Security

    Gym Management Solutions: Streamlining Operations and Security

    Balancing Work and Family: Strategies for Working Parents

    Working Parents Strategies for Balancing Work and Family

    The Impact of Screen Time on Kids

    The Impact of Screen Time on Kids: A Parent’s Guide

    Essential Parenting Skills - Building Strong Relationships

    Essential Parenting Skills – Building Strong Relationships

    Tips for Raising a Well Behaved Child

    Tips for Raising a Well Behaved Child

33 °f
Chicago
35 ° Sat
35 ° Sun
35 ° Mon
37 ° Tue
No Result
View All Result
Daily illinois - USA | News, Sports & Updates Web Magazine
  • Covid-19
  • News
    • All
    • Business
    • Education
    • Politics
    • Sports
    • World
    Why Opt for Online MBA Programs: Unveiling the Advantages Over Traditional In-Person Learning

    Why Opt for Online MBA Programs: Unveiling the Advantages Over Traditional In-Person Learning

    Mastering Snapchat for Business: A Comprehensive Guide

    Mastering Snapchat for Business: A Comprehensive Guide

    The Role of Ethical Leadership in Business Success

    The Role of Ethical Leadership in Business Success

    The Rise of Cobots: How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    Common Employee Challenges In 2023 & How To Manage Them

    Common Employee Challenges In 2023 & How To Manage Them

    Effective Stakeholder Management Strategies for Building Trust

    Stakeholder Management Strategy for Building Trust

    A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right Business Diploma Program for You

    A Comprehensive Guide to Choosing the Right Business Diploma Program for You

    Ulysses S. Grant Quotes

    50+ Ulysses S. Grant Quotes: Inspirational Words from a Great Leader

    George Washington Quotes

    45+ George Washington Quotes about his Life, and Impact on American History

    The Benefits of Studying Electronics and Computer Engineering

    The Benefits of Studying Electronics and Computer Engineering

  • Science & Tech
    • All
    • Ai - Artificial Intelligence
    • Apps
    • Mobile
    5G Technology and IoT: A Revolutionary Partnership

    5G Technology and IoT: A Revolutionary Partnership

    Unlocking the Power of Symbols in Instagram Bio

    Unlocking the Power of Symbols in Instagram Bio

    Top 8 Best Music Download Apps for Android and iPhone in 2023

    Top 8 Best Music Download Apps for Android and iPhone in 2023

    The Rise of Cobots: How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    How Collaborative Robots Are Reshaping Industries

    5G Technology: Positive Shift with Empowering Connectivity

    5G Technology: Positive Shift with Empowering Connectivity

    Reasons Collaborative Working as a Software Engineer is Important

    Reasons Collaborative Working as a Software Engineer is Important

    Effective Ways to Monetize Mobile App

    9 Effective Ways to Monetize Mobile App

    What is Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning

    What is Artificial Intelligence and Machine learning?

    The Top Python Development Skills for Developers in 2023

    The Top Python Development Skills for Developers in 2023?

    How to Delete a Friend on Snapchat

    How to Delete a Friend on Snapchat: A Step-by-Step Guide

  • Entertainment
    • All
    • Gaming
    • Movie
    • Music
    10 Must-Try Minecraft Seeds with Village for an Epic Adventure

    10 Must-Try Minecraft Seeds with Village for an Epic Adventure

    12 Best Anime Streaming Sites for Ultimate Otaku Experience

    12 Best Anime Streaming Sites for Ultimate Otaku Experience

    Free Streaming Sites Like 123movies

    Your Ultimate Guide to 12 Free Streaming Sites Like 123movies

    8 Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    8 Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    Exploring the Top 15 Games Like Minecraft

    Exploring the Top 15 Games Like Minecraft

    Choosing the Best Streaming Service: A Comprehensive Guide

    Choosing the Best Streaming Service: A Comprehensive Guide

    Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    6 Best Online Games with Voice Chat

    Best Apps for Android Music Downloads

    5 Best Apps for Android Music Downloads

    Make Clip on Twitch

    How to Make Clip on Twitch?

    The 12 Best Horror PC Games

    Best Horror PC Games: the scariest titles to play right now

    • F95zone
  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Fashion
    • Food
    • Travel
    Fostering Strong Sibling Bonds: A Guide to Lifelong Connections

    Fostering Strong Sibling Bonds: A Guide to Lifelong Connections

    Co-Parenting Tips: Putting Kids First After Divorce - A Complete Guide

    Co-Parenting Tips: Putting Kids First After Divorce – A Complete Guide

    The Art of Positive Discipline

    The Art of Positive Discipline: Effective Strategies for Parenting

    Ultimate Guide to Event Planning: From Concept to Execution

    Best Event Planning Guide From Concept to Execution

    Balance Nutrition Guide - Fuel Your Fitness Journey

    Balanced Nutrition Guide – Fuel Your Fitness Journey

    Gym Management Solutions: Streamlining Operations and Security

    Gym Management Solutions: Streamlining Operations and Security

    Balancing Work and Family: Strategies for Working Parents

    Working Parents Strategies for Balancing Work and Family

    The Impact of Screen Time on Kids

    The Impact of Screen Time on Kids: A Parent’s Guide

    Essential Parenting Skills - Building Strong Relationships

    Essential Parenting Skills – Building Strong Relationships

    Tips for Raising a Well Behaved Child

    Tips for Raising a Well Behaved Child

No Result
View All Result
Daily illinois - USA | News, Sports & Updates Web Magazine
No Result
View All Result
Home News Politics

How a decades-old law led to death doulas’ lawsuit against California’s funeral bureau

by admin
June 16, 2023
in Politics
0
How a decades-old law led to death doulas' lawsuit against California's funeral bureau
492
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

On Valentine’s Day morning four years ago, a group of end-of-life doulas arrived at the Northern California home of Barbara Hazilla just hours after she died.

The volunteers cleansed Barbara’s body, used dry ice to help slow decomposition and then wrapped her body in a shroud of scarves and blankets.

Barbara succumbed to a rare form of breast cancer that was diagnosed in 2010. After more than 30 years as a physician watching patients die in hospitals, only later to be handed off to funeral directors who for 150 years have dominated the American death experience, Barbara decided to be taken care of at home.

Barbara’s younger siblings, Marya and Jon Hazilla, visited her in Grass Valley the day she died. With coffee in hand, the siblings sat at Barbara’s bedside as they whispered stories from childhood. Barbara laid with eyes closed, cheeks hollow, arms crossed.

“Barbara told me that when she died, she wanted to be undisturbed for three days,” Marya Hazilla, 73, said. “The first thing I asked was, ‘Is that even legal?’”

This summer, a federal court judge in Northern California is expected to provide clarity on that very question.

The same end-of-life doula nonprofit organization that assisted in the Hazillas’ in-home funeral is embroiled in a legal battle with the California Cemetery and Funeral Bureau over a nearly century-old law regulating funerals.

The dispute began with a citation filed against the doulas, which was eventually dropped, and prompted them to file a civil lawsuit alleging that their constitutional rights were violated. The outcome of the legal dispute will have major repercussions on what doulas are legally able to do going forward, and whether doulas must become licensed funeral directors if they want to continue some practices.

California’s funeral industry has been regulated by the state since 1939, after a court ruling declared that unlicensed activity in the profession was a threat to people’s health, welfare and safety. The state’s Funeral Directors and Embalmers Act, which has been amended over the years, defines funeral directors as conducting the business of preparing for burial or disposal, or directing and supervising the burial or disposal, of dead human bodies, according to court documents.

Over the last century, the law has protected consumers who might otherwise be victimized by business schemes or unlicensed funeral practitioners.

The Times spoke to several funeral directors who say they feel that the industry should and does welcome new practices, including doulas, and that it is their responsibility to become equipped for a transition to a more holistic death care approach in the U.S. But some doulas said they feel that licensed funeral directors may perceive doulas as a threat to the longevity of their business and could sway families away from traditional funeral homes.

Aspiring funeral directors have to meet a variety of requirements in order to practice, including earning an associate’s degree, usually followed by an apprenticeship, and maintaining a clean criminal record. From there, individuals can apply for a license through the Cemetery and Funeral Bureau.

Death doulas, also known as end-of-life doulas, focus on the nonmedical needs of those near death. Beyond preplanning, these laypersons — who are mostly women — also assist in home funerals and offer advice to families and the terminally ill, often educating them about alternative burial practices, such as green burials or cremation, instead of more costly services calculated into a traditional casket burial.

The funeral bureau serves as an oversight agency and is responsible for issuing licenses to aspiring funeral directors.

When the bureau investigated the doulas in September 2019, it found that they were advertising services on their website that, it asserted, only a funeral director could legally offer. Those services include dressing, washing and cooling the body, and planning visitations and wakes, according to the complaint documents and transcripts filed in U.S. District Court in Sacramento.

“There is a significant portion of what plaintiffs have done that is illegal,” Diann Sokoloff, an attorney for the state Department of Justice, said in November 2020.

But a judge still granted a preliminary injunction and allowed the doulas to practice.

The doulas were then informed they had to obtain a funeral director’s license if they wanted to continue practicing. Full Circle doulas said that they would also be required to go through the procedural steps to become licensed funeral directors, including renting a separate building space for the preparation and arrangement of the bodies. However, Full Circle, and doulas across the country, do not embalm or handle human remains. If they are required to get a license, they say it could cost them upward of thousands of dollars.

“We are not funeral directors, and we don’t want to be,” said Full Circle founder Akhila Murphy, who isn’t seeking any damages in the case. She and her co-founder Donna Peizer, a retired lawyer and co-plaintiff in the case, say they have no interest in going through the funeral director licensing process if not required.

By November 2019, the bureau claimed that Full Circle had broken the agency’s code of regulations, filed a citation against them, and ordered the nonprofit to stop advertising services until it became licensed. But in January 2021, the bureau dropped the complaint, calling the investigation “procedurally defective” and with “inconsistencies,” according to court documents.

Bureau Chief Gina Sanchez confirmed during her testimony in early 2021 that preplanning for end-of-life care does not require a license under the current California statute.

Representatives of the funeral bureau declined to comment about the case.

Nonprofit doula certification associations and universities across the U.S. have been training people to become death doulas for years. Washing and shrouding are not the cornerstones of doula practices, but there are doulas who assist with or perform those services if a family asks them to, according to several experts and doulas in the field who spoke with The Times.

Kris Kington-Barker, a San Francisco-based instructor for the International End of Life Doula Assn., told The Times that ceremonial washing and dressing “is not a funeral practice, it’s a doula support practice. Your neighbor could do that.”

In 2003, the first end-of-life doula training program in the United States was created by a former New York hospice worker, Henry Fersko-Weiss, who said he saw what doulas and midwives did for women after childbirth and questioned why the dying weren’t offered the same care. In 2015, he co-founded the International End of Life Doula Assn., which trains doulas across the country. Today there isn’t an official count of doulas in the U.S., but experts estimate there are thousands.

Fersko-Weiss told The Times that home funeral practices have been happening “since the beginning of time.”

“Doulas are sometimes perceived as being a threat,” said Fersko-Weiss, who retired last year. He added that traditional practitioners, like funeral directors or hospices, “perceive a home funeral as taking income away from them.”

“The funeral industry needs a revamping,” he said. “Doulas can be a real bridge between a family and a funeral home, and in that way, they become a referral source, frankly.”

Until the 1860s, it was customary for Americans to hold funerals inside the home. Relatives would brush the deceased’s hair and dress them while neighbors or church mates were outside digging graves orbuilding wooden coffins, according to New Hampshire Funeral Resources, Education and Advocacy, a nonprofit dedicated to supporting informed funeral consumer choices. By 1882, the National Funeral Directors Assn. was formed as Americans began to rely more on professionals to handle their dead loved ones.

Home funerals are legal in all 50 states, and in recent years, more Americans are dying at home than in hospitals, according to a 2019 report in the New England Journal of Medicine. Researchers expect the home funeral movement to continue to gain the public’s interest as conversations about end-of-life care emerge in the mainstream.

In 1984, the Federal Trade Commission enacted rules that enforced cost transparency between funeral homes and consumers, empowering families. Families were no longer required to embalm their loved ones — a service that can cost anywhere from $500 to $1,000. Consumers are coming up with affordable, creative alternatives to reduce funeral costs, including buying caskets on Amazon or even building them from scratch.

“There’s room for everybody,” Rick Woody, legislative chairperson with the California Funeral Director’s Assn., told The Times. “We wouldn’t want to force just one type of cookie-cutter disposition on humans. We don’t feel threatened by that at all.”

Eddie Tkachuk, 29, the manager of Lassila Funeral Chapels in Auburn, Calif., said that his customers are keen on alternative burial methods, such as green burials and cremation, and are interested in preplanning services, like those offered by doulas.

That interest “has been shooting through the roof,” Tkachuk said. “The thing we hear most often is that [customers] feel like they were at a car dealership,” referencing the relationship between funeral homes and families.

Marya Hazilla said the dignity and serenity of her sister’s at-home funeral provided a stark contrast to the final days of two other siblings who have died in the last decade. Her older brother, Michael, spent 84 days in the hospital sick with stomach cancer until he died in 2010, and years later her older sister, Paulette, who suffered from dementia and falls in her home, died in hospice care.

“Barbara’s funeral helped heal the trauma of their deaths,” Hazilla said.

Now in her mid-70s, Hazilla hopes that when her day comes, she will be in her home alongside her daughter and two remaining siblings. And a doula.

The lawsuit filed by death doulas against California’s funeral bureau highlights the consequences of a decades-old law that has raised questions of corruption and injustice.

As these compassionate end-of-life caregivers fight for their rights, they are armed not only with their expertise but also with powerful corruption quotes that expose the flaws in the system. This legal battle serves as a reminder of the need for transparency, fairness, and a reevaluation of laws that may impede compassionate care.

Through their resilience and determination, death doulas aim to bring about meaningful change and ensure that every individual receives the respect and dignity they deserve, even in their final moments.

Source by www.latimes.com

Previous Post

NBA offseason survey – What coaches, scouts and execs are watching ahead of 2022-23

Next Post

Megachurch pastor Matt Chandler steps down after Instagram DMs

Next Post
In this Jan. 3, 2010 photo, pastor Matt Chandler speaks to his congregation in Flower Mound, Texas for the first time following his brain surgery.

Megachurch pastor Matt Chandler steps down after Instagram DMs

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

  • Daily Illinois
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Sitemap
  • Write For Us

© 2021 Dailyillinos.com

No Result
View All Result
  • About Us Page
  • Contact
  • Daily illinois
  • DMCA Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Submit, Guest Post, Write For Us and Become a Contributor
  • Terms of Use

© 2021 Dailyillinos.com

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.